The ITV Debate
I played football yesterday evening: distracted and short of sleep, I was rubbish. After getting the kids to bed I then dozed off in the bath and woke only just in time to watch the latest televised debate. Perhaps my fatigue and mild disorientation help explain why I found it rather depressing. Though Alastair Stewart hosted, the questions came from the studio audience amid a bit of a bear pit atmosphere. That's often a recipe for more heat than light, and so it proved.
Yesterday afternoon I wrote that Livingstone had been having slightly the better of the TV encounters, thanks mostly to Johnson's continuing inability to get his story straight on bendy buses. But no candidate emerged as a clear victor last night. It didn't help the event that some of the questioners had their facts wrong. One accused Johnson of writing that black people have lower IQs. He didn't: it was the rancid Spectator columnist Taki. Livingstone corrected the questioner, but went on to hammer the point that Johnson had been editor of the Spectator at the time. Johnson had been pre-armed with a riposte, claiming that anti-semitic material had appeared in a long-forgotten far left newspaper which he claimed, incorrectly*, that Livingstone had edited.
I'd say Livingstone - "the Labour mayor" as Johnson often calls him, hoping a bit of Brown stuff will stick - had the better of that exchange, but was more on the defensive over crime. The most dispiriting aspect of the debate was the three of them competing to sound the most "tough" on the subject amid the surrounding emotion. I think Paddick has the best policing policy, but the truth is that, like all politicians, they've all been making claims about crime that they can't justify and promises they're in no position to keep. As for the question on buses, the man asking it seemed even more confused about Johnson's policy than Johnson. The Blond's reply was to insist that he has said "repeatedly" that £100 million should take care of it. The truth is he's only been repeating the figure since letting it slip by accident in front of someone's camera phone in Edgware.
Perhaps I'm suffering from campaign fatigue. Perhaps they are too. How about holding the election a week early?
* My mistake. Livingstone was joint editor of Labour Herald for a time in the early Eighties. Thanks to those who've pointed this out.

Recent Comments